The Earned Secret: Why the Era of Serendipitous Success is Over

10 Jun 2024

Hi All!

Here is my weekly letter onmental models, performance, business, and entrepreneurship.

If you love this content (please share it), but also…

Check out my Podcast, connect with me on YouTube / Twitter.

You can also subscribe to my DAILY newsletter here.

What’s in today’s newsletter?

The days of stumbling upon a billion-dollar idea while doodling on a napkin are gone.

The low-hanging fruit of the internet boom has been picked clean, and the competition for attention and market share is more ruthless than ever.

But don't stress. This is actually your moment.

In a recent conversation with Chris Dixon, managing partner at a16z, we dissected the evolving landscape of innovation.

What we discovered is both sobering and exhilarating.

The old playbook – the one that promised overnight success and "unicorn" valuations for half-baked ideas – is officially dead.

But in its ashes, a new era of opportunity is being forged.

The opportunity of Earned Secrets.

We dove into:

  • The Demise of the "Lucky Break": Why relying on serendipity and chance encounters is a losing strategy in today's market.
  • The Rise of the "Earned Secret" Era: How deep domain expertise, unique insights, and relentless execution are the non-negotiables for building a lasting empire.
  • The Skillset for the Future: The essential traits and tactics you need to thrive in this new landscape of relentless competition and accelerated change.

This isn't a doom-and-gloom prophecy; it's a wake-up call to a new reality.

A reality where the rewards are greater than ever for those who are willing to put in the work, embrace the discomfort, and forge their own path.

The era of accidental billionaires is over.

This is the era of the earned secret.

It's time to rise above the noise, embrace the challenge, and stake your claim.

Are you in?

If you want to listen to the full podcast, listen on or on YouTube.

The Power of Unique Insight

This week, I had the privilege of speaking with Chris Dixon, managing partner at a16z, the venture capital titan.

Dixon's wisdom is like concentrated rocket fuel for entrepreneurial minds.

One of the most potent ideas we discussed is the "earned secret."

Dixon's concept is simple yet profound: the most successful startups are built on unique insights – "earned secrets" – that others miss.

This isn't about dumb luck or stumbling upon a random idea.

An earned secret is a deep, contrarian understanding that comes from years of experience, relentless learning, and a willingness to see the world differently.

If you're an entrepreneur aiming for exponential growth, this concept is your X-factor. It's the hidden engine that can propel your startup from good to unstoppable.

Howard Schultz's Earned Secret

Here’s how it works.

Howard Schultz, the visionary behind Starbucks, had an earned secret that transformed a small coffee bean roaster into a global phenomenon.

His secret wasn't about coffee itself but about the experience of coffee.

Schultz traveled to Italy and was captivated by the espresso bars, the sense of community, and the ritual of enjoying a well-crafted cup of coffee.

He saw an opportunity to bring this experience to America, a country where coffee was often viewed as a commodity, not a craft.

Schultz's earned secret was his understanding that coffee was more than just a beverage; it was a social lubricant, a daily ritual, and a symbol of connection.

He built Starbucks around this insight, creating a "third place" between home and work where people could relax, connect, and enjoy a moment of respite.

This was Schultz’s earned secret.

The Anatomy of an Earned Secret

So, what exactly is an earned secret?

Let's break it down:

  • Deep Expertise: It starts with immersion. You need to be knee-deep in your chosen field, understanding its nuances, pain points, and emerging trends. This could be a technical domain, a specific industry, or a niche market.

  • Contrarian Thinking: The best secrets often run counter to conventional wisdom. They challenge the status quo and reveal hidden opportunities. This requires independent thought, a healthy dose of skepticism, and the courage to question everything.

  • Unique Insight: This is where the magic happens. It's the "aha!" moment when all your knowledge and contrarian thinking crystallize into a powerful insight. This is the seed of your breakthrough innovation.

  • Validation: An earned secret isn't just a hunch; it's a hypothesis that needs to be tested and validated in the real world. This requires rigorous experimentation, data-driven analysis, and the willingness to adapt and iterate.

Earned Secrets in Action

Let's look at some real-world examples of earned secrets fueling extraordinary success:

  • Amazon: Jeff Bezos' earned secret was not simply believing in the internet, but recognizing the untapped power of long-tail markets online. While traditional bookstores were limited by shelf space, Bezos saw that the internet could offer a near-infinite selection, catering to niche interests and creating a new paradigm of customer choice. This insight led to the creation of the "everything store," fundamentally disrupting how we shop and consume.

  • Tesla: Elon Musk's earned secret extended beyond the viability of electric vehicles. He saw the potential to completely redefine the automotive industry by making EVs not just "green," but also high-performance, desirable status symbols. This contrarian view challenged the perception of electric cars as slow and unappealing, paving the way for a luxury brand that disrupted the traditional auto market.

  • Airbnb: Brian Chesky and Joe Gebbia's earned secret went deeper than realizing people would share their homes. They tapped into a growing desire for authentic travel experiences. They understood that travelers weren't just looking for a place to stay, but a way to connect with local cultures and communities. This insight led to a platform that disrupted the traditional hotel industry by offering unique, personalized accommodations.

Some Thoughts:

  • These earned secrets weren't just good ideas; they were fundamental shifts in thinking that challenged existing paradigms.
  • Each secret tapped into latent demand or underserved needs that weren't being addressed by existing solutions.
  • These insights were deeply personal and rooted in the founder's experiences and passions.
  • The execution of these earned secrets required vision, courage, and the ability to rally others around a contrarian idea.

These entrepreneurs didn't just have good ideas; they had earned secrets.

These unique insights gave them an unfair advantage, allowing them to create products and services that fundamentally changed the world.

Two Kinds of Earned Secrets

Your earned secret isn't a one-size-fits-all concept.

It comes in two distinct flavors, each with its own unique pathway to discovery:

Access: The Insider's Advantage

These are the secrets hidden behind closed doors, the whispers in boardrooms, the data buried deep within proprietary systems.

Access-based earned secrets come from having a unique vantage point that others lack. Remember, information is power. The more access you have, the more likely you are to uncover a hidden gem.

Revelation: The Art of Synthesis

These are the secrets hidden in plain sight, waiting to be revealed by a fresh perspective or a new way of thinking. Revelation-based earned secrets come from synthesizing existing information in a novel way. Think like a detective. Look for clues, connect the dots, and piece together the puzzle to uncover the hidden truth.

Your Hidden Earned Secrets

You may already possess earned secrets without even realizing it. Your unique experiences, knowledge, and perspective give you a distinct lens through which to view the world.

By sharing your ideas and engaging in conversations with others, you can uncover these hidden gems and turn them into powerful assets.

But of course the question is… how?

Unearthing Your Earned Secret

Now that you understand the power of earned secrets, how do you find your own?

This is a simple framework I've developed to help you unearth your own earned secret.

Here's your roadmap:

Embrace the Unknown

Innovation thrives at the edges, where disciplines collide. Think of it as cross-training for your brain.

  • Play "Conference Roulette": Pick a conference outside your industry – biotech, art, even a blockchain summit. You'll be amazed at the unexpected connections you'll make.
  • Create a "Mental Bento Box": Curate a reading list that's as diverse as your favorite sushi platter. Toss in a biography of a historical figure, a sci-fi novel, and the latest research on consumer behavior.
  • Join the "Other" LinkedIn Groups: Don't just stick to your industry echo chambers. Lurk in groups for marketers, engineers, or even urban planners. You never know what spark might ignite your next big idea.
  • Tactical Insight: The most interesting people are rarely found in the most obvious places.

Look for Friction

Pain points are like diamonds in the rough – they're valuable, but you have to dig for them.

  • Go Undercover Boss: Become a customer of your competitors. Take meticulous notes on every frustration, every "ugh" moment, and every feature you wish existed.
  • Host "Venting Hours": Schedule regular, informal virtual meetings where customers can rant about their problems. Offer a free drink or a discount code as an incentive.
  • Become a Reddit Lurker: Dive into subreddits relevant to your industry. Pay attention to the threads that get the most upvotes and comments. These are goldmines of unfiltered customer feedback.
  • Tactical Insight: The best entrepreneurs are part therapist, part detective. Listen deeply, ask probing questions, and connect the dots to uncover the hidden needs and desires.

Follow Your Obsessions

Your passions are the breadcrumbs leading you to your entrepreneurial destiny.

  • Carve Out "Passion Time": Schedule dedicated time each week to indulge in your hobbies and interests. Let your mind wander, explore new ideas, and connect with your inner child.
  • Become a "Micro-Expert": Pick a niche topic that fascinates you and dive deep. Read academic papers, attend specialized workshops, and connect with other enthusiasts. Become the go-to person for that specific area of knowledge.
  • Share Your Obsession: Start a blog, podcast, or YouTube channel about your passion. Not only will you attract like-minded people, but you'll also solidify your own understanding and potentially discover new business opportunities.
  • Tactical Insight: The most successful businesses are often built on the founder's genuine passion for a problem or a solution. Don't underestimate the power of your obsessions.

Experiment and Iterate

Action beats analysis paralysis. Don't let perfectionism hold you back.

  • Launch a "Pre-Totype": Before building a full-fledged prototype, create a simple mockup or landing page to gauge interest and gather feedback.
  • Run "Micro-Experiments": Test small variations of your product or service to see what resonates with customers. Use A/B testing, surveys, and social media polls to get quick feedback.
  • Embrace the "Pivot": Be willing to change course if your initial idea isn't working. Sometimes the most successful businesses start with a completely different concept.
  • Tactical Insight: Think of your business as a scientific experiment. The goal is to gather data, learn from your mistakes, and constantly refine your approach.

Build a Network of Thinkers: Your network is your net worth, but it's not about collecting LinkedIn connections. It's about building genuine relationships with people who challenge and inspire you.

  • Seek Out "Uncommon Minds": Don't just surround yourself with people who think like you. Look for individuals with diverse backgrounds, experiences, and perspectives.
  • Host "Dinner Salons": Invite a small group of interesting people from different fields for an evening of conversation and idea exchange.
  • Become a "Super Connector": Introduce people who you think would benefit from knowing each other. The more connections you make, the richer your network becomes.
  • Tactical Insight: Remember, it's not just about who you know, but who knows you. Make yourself valuable to others by sharing your knowledge, offering help, and being a generous collaborator.

A few final thoughts…

Immersion, Not Just Information:

Don't just skim the surface; dive into the depths of your chosen field.

Obsessively consume books, articles, podcasts – whatever gets your synapses firing. But more importantly, get your hands dirty.

Talk to the people in the trenches, the ones who live and breathe the problems you're trying to solve.

Go beyond the obvious sources.

Hunt down obscure forums, niche subreddits, and industry Slack channels.

Talk to disgruntled ex-employees, passionate hobbyists, and even your competitors' customers.

The most valuable insights often come from unexpected places.

Curiosity Kills Complacency:

Ask the questions that make others uncomfortable.

Challenge the assumptions that everyone else takes for granted.

Be the one who dares to say, "What if we did it this way instead?"

Remember, the most groundbreaking ideas often start with a simple "why?".

Keep a "question journal."

Jot down every curious thought, nagging doubt, or "what if" scenario that pops into your head.

Review it regularly to spark new lines of inquiry.

Contrarianism as a Compass:

Zig when everyone else zags.

The road less traveled is often where you'll find the most valuable insights.

Don't be afraid to swim against the current of conventional wisdom.

The best entrepreneurs are the ones who see what others miss.

Create a "devil's advocate" board – a group of trusted advisors who will relentlessly challenge your ideas and assumptions.

Embrace the discomfort of dissenting opinions; it can lead to breakthroughs.

Synthesis: The Art of Connecting Dots:

Your brain is a pattern-recognition machine.

Feed it a diverse diet of information, and it'll start making connections that others haven't seen.

Look for the hidden patterns, the underlying principles, the surprising links between seemingly unrelated ideas.

This is where the magic happens.

Action Trumps Analysis:

Ideas are a dime a dozen.

Execution is the game-changer.

Don't get stuck in analysis paralysis.

Build, test, iterate.

Fail fast, learn faster.

The only way to know if your earned secret is truly a secret weapon is to put it to the test.

Adopt the "build-measure-learn" loop popularized by Eric Ries in The Lean Startup.

Focus on rapid experimentation, data-driven decision-making, and continuous improvement.

To Summarize

Look, we've danced around the fancy jargon and dissected the "earned secret" concept.

But let's cut to the chase: it's not about the idea itself, it's about the relentless hustle to unearth it.

Don't get it twisted.

Your secret isn't going to magically appear like a winning lottery ticket.

It's buried deep, forged in the trenches of experience, intellect, and insatiable curiosity.

And the world doesn't give a damn about your potential.

It rewards those who deliver results.

It craves innovation, not regurgitated clichés. It demands solutions, not empty promises.

So, here's the reality check:

Stop waiting for permission.

Stop looking for shortcuts.

Stop blaming the universe for not handing you the answers on a silver platter.

Get your ass in gear.

Embrace the discomfort of the unknown.

Challenge the norms that hold you back.

Pursue knowledge like your life depends on it.

If you can't even get yourself to do that, you might as well quit now. Seriously.

The world needs your unique vision, your disruptive ideas, and your relentless determination.

But it won't wait for you to get your act together.

So, stop talking and start doing.

This is your moment. This is your earned secret.

Own it.


If you want to listen to the full podcast, listen on or on YouTube.